Ethereum Improvement Proposals - a field shaping Ethereum Network and Web3

Mar 10, 2023 11:11:00 AM
Let's talk about Ethereum Improvement Proposals (EIPs) - the standards that determine what's hot and what's not in Ethereum. Think of EIPs as the "source of truth" for the community, providing technical specifications for potential new features or processes. Through the EIP process, network upgrades and application standards for Ethereum are discussed and developed - it's like a brainstorming session, but with more acronyms.
Ethereum Improvement Proposals (EIPs) are technical standards that outline potential new features or processes for Ethereum. They serve as the definitive source for the Ethereum community, providing specifications for network upgrades and application standards.
EIPs can be created by anyone within the Ethereum community, but they must adhere to the guidelines outlined in EIP-1. This includes providing a concise technical specification, along with a brief explanation of the motivation behind the proposal. EIP authors are responsible for gaining consensus within the community and documenting alternative viewpoints.
While anyone can create an EIP, historically, most authors have been application or protocol developers due to the technical expertise required. Nonetheless, the EIP process is open to all and encourages participation from a wide range of stakeholders to foster innovation and collaboration.
Ethereum Improvement Proposals (EIPs) are essential for proposing and discussing changes to the network. Below we will discuss in detail what each component of an EIP entails.

How does EIPs work?

The EIP process is explicit and starts with the author of an idea presenting their proposal. This initial phase requires a thorough explanation of why the proposal should be accepted along with supportive evidence to demonstrate its necessity. During this stage, authors need to acquire feedback from the community to refine and enhance their ideas.
The next phase is to draft the concept, precisely fulfilling all of the criteria for an EIP. This will be a continual work in progress that can continually evolve until it's considered finished and ready to ascend onto the subsequent stage.
The revised draft is then showcased on the EIPS Ethereum website to garner as much attention from the community as possible. This last stage of implementation seeks to perfect any errors and create a fully improved version of the EIP that can be used by all.
When an EIP passes the last call stage, it is ready to enter acceptance - that means virtually no changes can be made and Ethereum client developers should consider implementing this specific EIP. While deciding whether or not to modify it on clients as part of a hard fork isn't covered by the EIP process, rest assured that this status only applies to core blockchain processes!
To complete the process, you must present your EIP. At this juncture, simply make any corrections to misprints that may have occurred during earlier stages of the procedure. Depending on what is necessary for the specific project, other states can also be marked such as assets, cancelled, rejected and replaced when applicable.
Overall, the EIP process is a collaborative effort that involves the entire Ethereum community. By following this well-defined process, the community can make sure that proposed changes are thoroughly vetted, tested, and implemented in a way that benefits the entire network.

What are the EIP components?

The different components consist of a preamble, abstract, motivation, specification, rationale, backwards compatibility as well as test cases - all with their distinct purpose. When these parts come together they form a comprehensive picture showcasing precisely how this change can impact the protocol positively or negatively.
The initial section of an EIP is the preamble, which provides crucial data about the EIP. This includes a short yet descriptive title (up to 44 characters), along with its corresponding description (limited to 140 characters) and author details. However, neither the title nor the description must feature its assigned EIP number.
The Abstract is a succinct technical summary of the EIP, composed of several sentences. It should be easily understandable yet concise enough for anyone to quickly grasp the main idea behind this specification. If your submission intends to adjust the Ethereum protocol, an optional but essential 'Motivation' section must accompany it. This paragraph needs to express why current protocols don't address and solve the problem that your EIP attempts to tackle - otherwise, you may omit this part altogether if its purpose is self-evident.
Crafting the specification section of an Ethereum Improvement Proposal (EIP) is essential. It should provide a thorough explanation for any new feature in terms of syntax and semantics so that users can have access to numerous compatible implementations on various Ethereum platforms such as Besu, Erigon, EthereumJs, Go-ethereum, Nethermind - or others.
The rationale section expands the specification by outlining what inspired the design and why those specific decisions were made. It should also include other designs that were explored, such as how similar features are provided in other languages. Furthermore, it should address any objections or doubts brought up during the debate regarding this EIP (Ethereum Improvement Proposal).
If a proposal introduces backward incompatibilities, it is of paramount importance to include the Backwards Compatibility section. This should be done to explain how these changes will affect users as well as provide information on how authors propose dealing with them. If there are no backward incompatibilities, however, this can be omitted from the EIP document entirely.
If your EIP is affecting consensus changes, the test cases section is a necessary but optional addition. Include input/expected output pairs as data right in the EIP itself or provide them in ../assets/eip-.
To sum up, Ethereum Improvement Proposals, or EIPs, are an essential component of the Ethereum network's ongoing development. EIPs allow for community-driven changes to be made to the Ethereum blockchain, ensuring that the network remains secure, efficient, and up-to-date. EIP involves composing a proposal that has several significant sections. By comprising the preamble, abstract, motivation, specification rationale and backward compatibility as well as test cases in its structure; this framework serves a distinct purpose - to precisely summarise technical details while examining any potential discrepancies with existing structures. Crafting an EIP with a holistic approach can amplify the advantages of Ethereum protocol initiatives. By adhering to this process, developers and stakeholders work together to elevate not just the network but also its environment as a whole. In doing so, everyone involved can ensure that their contributions result in positive enhancements for Ethereum’s advancement.

Do you have an open source project?

As communities, be it the Ethereum community or the open-source ecosystem we must come together and solve one of the most pressing problems all large communities face: coordination. This is why we made Cyberfame - a team of open source and blockchain enthusiasts, cyber security experts, artists, and engineers who are passionate about developing innovative solutions that make managing cyber security data a breeze.
Our tool is designed to scan and organize cyber security data in a fast, engaging, and approachable way, with a special (though not exclusive) focus on open-source projects. You can Check out our Ethereum network case study here.
We're always looking for ways to support open-source development and promote cybersecurity, which is why we offer a trial program and support for open-source projects at special rates. If you're an open-source project looking for reliable cybersecurity tools, we've got you covered.
Visit to learn more, or email us if you want to talk directly to us about your project.
Thanks for reading!